Energy Recovery Inc
For the period ended Dec 31, 2023. Filed Feb 21, 2024.
View on SEC.govAbout this filing
A company's yearly report to the SEC, with audited financial statements. It is the fullest account a company gives of its business, its finances and the risks it sees.
FY2023 · Filed Feb 21, 2024
Extracted filing text, with the paragraph anchors used by the comparison.
See the whole filing, with its images and exhibitsContents
Item 1. Business
Energy Recovery, Inc. (the “Company”, “Energy Recovery”, “we”, “our” and “us”) is a trusted global leader in energy efficiency
technology. We design and manufacture reliable, high-performance solutions that provide cost savings through improved energy efficiency in
commercial and industrial processes, with applications across several industries. With a strong foundation in the desalination industry, we
have delivered transformative solutions that help our customers optimize their operations and reduce their energy consumption for more than
30 years. We believe that our customers do not have to sacrifice quality and cost savings for sustainability; and we are committed to
developing solutions that drive long-term value from a technical, financial, and environmental perspective.
We have been incorporated in the state of Delaware since 2001. Our corporate headquarters, principal research and development
(“R&D”), and manufacturing facility is located in San Leandro, California. In addition, we have manufacturing and warehouse space in Tracy,
California and offices, warehouse space and ayard in Katy, Texas. We have a global direct sales team and on-site technical support staff to
service customers inthe United States of America (the “U.S.”), Europe, Latin America, the Middle East, and Asia.
Sustainability
Our technology harnesses the powerful combination of performance and energy efficiency to deliver operational profitability and help
our customers achieve environmentally sustainable operations. As such, we are committed to measuring and managing our own operational
impact, as well as producing high-quality energy recovery devices for our customers. While sustainability has always been central to our
business, four years ago we embarked on our formal sustainability journey to turn the lens on ourselves and provide our stakeholders with
further transparency around our company. Our integrated sustainability strategy includes a dedicated sustainability team, internal
sustainability programs focused on key goals with measurable targets, and sustainability solutions for our customers.
Oursustainability goals, which we believe are highly influential to our business, were first announced in our 2020 Sustainability
Report. These goals focus onfour sustainability topics –Employees, Environmental & Climate Change Risks, Innovation & Opportunity, and
Products. These topics were identified by our management team and our stakeholders as material to our company’s ability to create value.
We believe ourgoals provide us with a strategic roadmap to become a more sustainable and resilient business, and hold us accountable as
we strive to be a responsible corporate citizen. In accordance with our strategic roadmap, we announced our first corporate emissions
reduction target in 2023 and have committed to reducing our greenhouse gas emissions as outlined in our 2022 Sustainability Report.
Employees. Our employees are integral to success and innovation. It is our firm commitment and responsibility to provide a safe and
supportive working environment for our staff where initiative is rewarded, suggestions are valued, and ideas to enhance our company or our
products are implemented. Likewise, it is our responsibility to offer ample opportunities for employees to develop their skills. For more
information on our employees and programs, please see Human Capital Resources below.
Environmental & Climate Change Risks. We are engaged in a comprehensive assessment to identify our short-, medium-, and long-
term climate-related risks and opportunities. As our business grows, we are vigilant in managing our climate-related risks to remain
successful and competitive in an ever-changing environment.
Innovation & Opportunity. Innovation and a trusted relationship with our customers and industry partners is pivotal to this goal, as this
allows us to understand our customers’ needs and pain points. By partnering with our customers and consistently striving to improve, we are
confident in our continued ability to contribute to our customers’ operational profitability while advancing environmental sustainability.
Products. We uphold the trust of the industries we serve by meticulously manufacturing products that not only deliver exceptional
performance and generate significant value, but also demonstrate reliability and safety. At our core, we aim to design and manufacture high-
quality innovative products that deliver significant value to customers and help foster environmentally sustainable operations.
In 2023, we surveyed and interviewed investors, employees, and customers to ensure our sustainability strategy remains aligned with
the evolution of our business. The results of this assessment process and any associated adjustments to our sustainability priorities, goals,
and roadmap will be disclosed in our forthcoming 2023 Sustainability Report.
Detailed disclosures on our sustainability performance can be found in our recent 2022 Sustainability Report, which is available for
download on our website at: https://energyrecovery.com/sustainability/. We have included this website address only as an inactive textual
reference and do not intend it to be an active link to our website.
Pressure Exchanger Technology
Our pressure exchanger technology platform is at the heart of many of our solutions. It is designed to efficiently capture and transfer
pressure energy, making commercial and industrial processes more efficient and environmentally sustainable, thereby lowering costs, saving
energy, and minimizing emissions. This versatile technology is applicable to a wide range of industries that utilize pressurized fluids,
including liquids and gas, and is ideal for a wide range of pressure ratings.
Our pressure exchanger technology acts like a fluid piston, efficiently transferring energy between high- and low-pressure liquid and/
or gas through continuously rotating ducts. Key to the operation of a pressure exchanger is the micron-level clearances between the rotor
and the pressure exchanger’s stationary components, including the sleeve and the end covers. Fluid circulating within this clearance acts as
a lubricated bearing, minimizing frictional losses and wear for an extremely efficient exchange of pressure energy.
The original product application of our pressure exchanger technology, the PX® Pressure Exchanger® (“PX”)energy recovery device
was a major contributor to the advancementof seawater reverse osmosis desalination (“SWRO”) globally, addressing “energy intensity”,
which is a key pain point for the industry. The PX, which we believe is today’s industry standard in energy recovery in desalination, reduces
energy use by up to 60% in SWRO facilities. It is this significant savings that allowed SWRO to supplant thermal desalination as today’s
desalination technology of choice. Today we continue to push the boundaries of our core technology to handle different operating
environments and industrial applications and deliver reliable, high-performance solutions that generate cost savings and increase energy
efficiency for our customers.
Water Treatment
Markets
The need for clean water and energy optimization around the world is intensifying, driven by population growth, industrialization, rapid
urbanization, and climate change. Apart from seasonal variations, the attainable supply of fresh water generally remains fixed and is already
decreasing in some geographic areas, as we believe that the reliability of rainfall grows more erratic in many geographies, water levels drop
in rivers and aquifers, and rising oceans encroach on historically fresh water sources near the coasts. These trends make the markets we
serve, such as desalination and wastewater treatment, increasingly critical to meet growing global water demand. Our goal is to lower the
costs and emissions associated with water production and treatment in the desalination and wastewater markets, respectively. In addition,
we help the end user in their sustainability compliance goals.
Reverse osmosis (“RO”) is the preferred technology in the vast majority of desalination facilities and growing in importance in
wastewater applications. As an industry leader inenergy recovery devices, we deliver efficient, scalable solutions for recovering otherwise
wasted energy in the RO process, thereby helping our customers lower their operating costs and reduce carbon emissions.
Desalination
Worldwide seawater desalination plants using our products produce over 30 million cubic meters of water per day (“m 3/day”), enough
to provide for more than 25% of U.S. population’s daily water needs athome. As water scarcity grows in communities across the globe, we
are proud of our impact in enabling more affordable, sustainable access to this vital resource.
Typical Process Flow Diagram
*Main pump size reduced by up to 60% compared to a SWRO process not using any energy recovery device.
Seawater Reverse Osmosis Desalination. Energy intensive pumps are used to pressurize feed waters with varying concentrations of
salts, minerals and contaminants, which is then pumped through a semi-permeable membrane to achieve the desired water quantity and
quality. This process results in fresh water, suitable for potable, agricultural and industrial use and a highly concentrated and pressurized
concentrate or brine stream. Rather than dissipating or “wasting” the pressure energy from the discharge brine, our PX, the most commonly
adopted energy recovery solution, can transfer the pressure energy from the high-pressure discharge stream directly to a portion of the low-
pressure filtered feed water stream, thereby reducing the amount of flow required by the main high-pressure process pumps, which are the
largest consumers of power within the SWRO process. Our highly efficient technology can recycle this pressure energy atpeak efficiencies
up to 98%. This results in a more efficient process as the size of the high-pressure pumps are greatly reduced, no longer needed to be sized
for full membrane feed flow, and are now re-sized for the permeate flow, thus reducing the energy usage by up to 60%, compared to a
system without energy recovery devices. As a result, our PXs have helped make seawater desalination an economically viable and more
sustainable option in the production of potable water.
Brackish Water Reverse Osmosis Desalination. The brackish RO process is similar to that of the SWRO process. Brackish water
typically has lower salt, mineral and contaminant content than seawater, therefore, fewer solids need to be removed and less energy is
expended on pressurizing the feed water. Due to the lower cost and available pressure energy involved, our low pressure PX andhydraulic
turbochargers generally have characteristics more applicable to the brackish process. The salt content in the feed water will ultimately
determine the system design and operating conditions which, in turn, will drive decisions related to the specification or type ofenergy
recovery device to be employed, if any.
Seawater desalination has been our primary market for revenue generation, and brackish water applications are an emerging area of
potential growth. These markets range from small, decentralized desalination plants, such as those used in cruise ships and resorts, to
large-scale project (“megaproject”) desalination plants, defined as those which produce over 50 thousand m 3/day. Because of the
geographical location of many significant water desalination projects, geopolitical and economic events can influence the timing of expected
projects. We anticipate that markets traditionally not associated with desalination, such as the U.S. and China, will inevitably develop and
provide further revenue growth opportunities.
Both seawater and brackish market opportunities are represented by newly constructed (“greenfield”) and existing (“brownfield”) water
treatment projects. These opportunities include retrofits, upgrades, and plant expansions, that either operate without an energy recovery
device or utilize alternative energy recovery device technologies. The large-scale greenfield market has been the key market for our water
business and represents projects that are typically public in nature and involve a formal tendering process; while smaller projects, may be
private in nature, may or may not involve a formal tendering process. Typical brownfield facilities face higher energy consumption and
reduced plant availability due to legacy technologies and aging equipment and include improvements to existing operations, equipment
upgrades and potential expansions of existing capacity.
We work directly with the project bidders, generally large project developers, engineering, procurement, and construction firms (“EPC”
firm), end-users, and industry consultants, to specify our products prior to the project being awarded, where possible. Once the project is
awarded to an EPC firm, our normal sales process ensues. The greenfield market is highly competitive, and the tendering process pays
close attention to the cost to desalinate water (i.e., dollars per cubic meter of water produced). Retrofit opportunities may or may not have a
formal tendering process. We typically approach the plant owners, operators, and/or end-users of these facilities to present our leading life-
cycle cost value-proposition.
Wastewater
Thewastewater market has more variety and covers a wide range of industries and geographies. As governments across the globe
increase their focus on water conservation, reuse, recycling, and limiting the amount of pollution, they are establishing more stringent
requirements forwastewater treatment to maximize water recovery, and to comply with growing freshwater withdrawal and discharge
regulations. Zero orminimum liquid discharge (“ZLD” and “MLD”, respectively) applications are being observed in countries throughout the
world. We expect this trend to continue to expand as we observe the implementation of regulations on the discharge ofwastewater effluents
as the world responds to the growing gap between water availability and demand while focusing on minimizing and/or eliminating pollution
from these industries.
Energy Recovery Devices Utilized During Each Stage in the Treatment Train
Many municipal and industrial industries are willing to adopt more sustainable water reuse practices and to reduce their reliance on
existing water resources. Sectors such as automotive, including electric vehicles, chemicals, pulp and paper, textiles, semiconductors, and
other heavy industries are often large water consumers. Their water usage can compete with municipal and agricultural water resources,
further straining potable water supply in areas already struggling with water scarcity.
A variety of RO technologies may be utilized in thewastewater applications where our energy recovery solutions are applicable. Such
processes are typically multi-staged, with each stage increasing in pressure as the wastewater is filtered to recover clean water from a
wastewater stream and concentrate pollutants to a level where they can be economically utilized or safely disposed, rather than discharged
into the environment. Our energy recovery solutions, such as ourhydraulic turbochargers, low-pressure PX, and our Ultra PX, can be
applied to each of these stages.
Technology Conversion
The thermal desalination process was the dominant seawater desalination technology employed throughout the 1990s. In this
process, thermal energy is used to evaporate water from heated seawater and subsequently condenses the vapor to produce fresh potable
water. Starting in the early 1990s, due to many factors including the introduction and greater usage ofenergy recovery devices, the process
of choice for the desalination industry shifted from thermal- to membrane-based RO desalination.
Over the past two decades RO desalination technology has become the predominant technology, supplanting thermal desalination
technology as today’s desalination technology of choice. As water desalination plants that use the thermal desalination technology age, the
industry expects the majority of these plant owners to replace their existing thermal technology with RO desalination technology. These
conversions are driving new demand for RO desalination equipment, which in turn creates demand for our products.
We also see a similar technology conversion in thewastewater market. Thermal technologies have been the technology of choice for
RO systems seeking to maximize the removal of waste from the water used in the manufacturing process, such as in “ZLD” processes, where
all water is recovered and contaminants are reduced to solid waste, and MLD processes, where near-ZLD processes produce small volumes
of liquid waste. Similar to seawater desalination, thermal technologies are an energy- and cost-intensive method for cleaning water in these
discharge processes, with up to 50 percent of costs typically stemming from thermal treatments. Adopting ultra high-pressure reverse
osmosis (“UHPRO”) treatment methods to achieve ZLD and MLD objectives moves the cost of these thermal technologies further
downstream. Our PX U Series pressure exchangers further reduce wasted energy of the UHPRO process by returning pressure energy to
the system, ultimately reducing overall energy costs and potentially lowering capital expenditures.
Water Treatment Solutions
Pressure Exchangers
Our line of pressure exchangers are high efficiency isobaric energy recovery devices made of a ceramic cartridge supported by a
highly efficient hydrodynamic and hydrostatic bearing system. Models in this product family are designed for use in a variety of reverse
osmosis systems within the water treatment industry, including seawater and brackish desalination, and wastewater treatment.
High Pressure PX Pressure Exchanger. Our highly efficient PX Pressure Exchanger family ofenergy recovery device
products delivers unmatched energy savings for water treatment systems. We offer a variety of sizes defined by the flow and
pressure requirements of the system ranging as low as 20 and up to 400 gallons per minute (“gpm”) (as low as 4.5 and up to
90.8 cubic meters of water per hour (“m 3/h”)) per device at pressures between 400-1200 pounds per square inch (“psi”)
(28-84 kilograms per square centimeter (“bar”)); however, our customers can design their energy recovery systems to achieve
unlimited capacities by installing an array of PXs in parallel.
Small and large desalination projects around the world rely on our range of PXs to achieve optimal operations and
maximum energy savings, and we believe the scalability and versatility of our PX can achieve similar success in the emerging
wastewater markets we are targeting.
Ultra PX. Our Ultra PX energy recovery device which, we believe, addresses key challenges, such as energy intensity
and environmental impacts associated with treating wastewater in a variety of water treatment applications. Designed with
thepressure exchanger technology that powers our flagship high pressure PX, the Ultra PX, functions similarly to our PX but
can withstand higher pressures. We offer a variety of sizes defined by the flow and pressure requirements of the system
ranging as low as 10 and up to 250 gpm (or as low as 2.3 and up to 56.8 m 3/h) per device at pressures between
1200-1800 psi (84-126 bar); however, by installing an array of PXs in parallel, our customers can design their energy
recovery system to achieve unlimited capacities.
While reverse osmosis adoption inwastewater treatment is growing, we believe our Ultra PX can help accelerate
further adoption of reverse osmosis in the growing zero and minimum liquid discharge markets by
enhancing RO’s affordability and efficiency compared to thermal treatment options, similar to the impact of
our PX in the seawater desalination market.
Low Pressure PX. Products in this family are ideal for municipal and industrial potable water reuse applications
that deploy low-pressure RO stages such as municipal wastewater reuse applications. We offer a variety of sizes defined
by the flow and pressure requirements of the system ranging as low as 30 and up to 260 gpm (or as low as 6.8 and up to
59.0 m 3/h) per device at pressures between 80-400 psi (6-28 bar); however, by installing an array of PXs in parallel, our
customers can design their energy recovery system to achieve unlimited capacities.
Pumps and Turbochargers
We offer high-pressure centrifugal pumps designed to complement ourenergy recovery devices for a wide range of
RO plant capacities and applications.
Hydraulic turbochargers. Our AT and LPThydraulic turbochargers are high efficiency centrifugal
energy recovery devices used in low-pressure brackish and high-pressure seawater desalination
systems andwastewater treatment markets. Our turbocharger product lines are highly efficient with
state-of-the-art engineering in a compact configuration. With custom-designed hydraulics that allow for
optimum performance over a wide range of operating conditions, our turbocharger technology offers
solutions to capital cost constrained single-stage RO applications, inter-stage boost applications
typically found in brackish water desalination and some wastewater treatment systems.
We believe ourhydraulic turbochargers deliver substantial savings, operational benefits, and ease of integration into systems.
Pumps. RO requires specialized high-pressure membrane feed and, in pressure exchanger applications,
high-pressure circulation pumps. We manufacture and/or supply specialized high-pressure feed and circulation
pumps for only a portion of the markets served by our energy recovery solutions. Our high-pressure feed pumps
are designed to pressurize the membrane feed flow and overcome the osmotic pressure requirements of the feed
water resulting in the production ofdesalinated water. Our high-pressure circulation pumps are designed to
circulate and control the high-pressure flow through our PX and to compensate for small pressure losses across
the membranes, PX and associated process piping in many desalination and wastewater applications.
Sales and Marketing
Our strategically located direct sales force offers our products through capital sale to our customers around the world. We maintain a
sales and service footprint in strategic territories, such as in the U.S., China, India, Latin America, Spain, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab
Emirates, allowing rapid response to our customers’ needs. Our team is comprised of individuals with many years of desalination and
wastewater treatment industry expertise. Aligned to the geographic breadth of our current and potential future customers, our product
marketing approach includes a strategic presence at water industry events across various regions. In addition, we leverage our industry and
market intelligence to develop new solutions and services that can be adopted by our growing customer base.
A significant portion of our revenue is from outside of the U.S. Additional segment and geographical information regarding our
product revenue is included in Note 2, “Revenue,” Note 9, “Segment Reporting,” and Note 10, “Concentrations,”of the Notes to Consolidated
Financial Statements in Part II, Item 8, “Financial Statements and Supplementary Data,” of this Annual Report on Form 10-K (the “Notes”).
Competition
As the water industry has evolved, we faced, and continue to face, increasing worldwide competition based on product offerings and
service. While our technology has been embraced for many years as the industry standard in RO desalination plants, the competition has
increased over time whereby more companies are offering energy recovery devices similar to our devices. Furthermore, we expect our
competition to begin offering new products that incorporate newer technology and materials that may work with existing and new RO
desalination and wastewater operations. We believe our flagship PX has a competitive advantage over products offered by our competitors,
because our devices (1)are made with highly durable and corrosion-resistant aluminum oxide (“alumina”)ceramic parts that are designed for
a life of more than 25 years; (2) are, in certain circumstances, warrantied for high efficiencies; and (3)cause minimal unplanned and planned
downtime, resulting in lower lifecycle cost and cost-effective energy recovery solutions. In addition, our PX offers optimum scalability in both
the desalination and growing wastewater market with a quick startup and no scheduled maintenance, as well as having been proven in the
market and trusted by our customers.
Project Channels
We separate our Water segment salesinto three distinct channels that are related to financial, other commercial, and technical
aspects of the projects. We identify these sales channels asmegaproject (“MPD”), original equipment manufacturers (“OEM”) and
aftermarket (“AM”).
Megaproject. MPD customers are major firms that develop, design, build, own and/or operate large-scale desalination plants with
capacities greater than 13.2 million gallons/day (50 thousand m 3/day). A majority of our water treatment revenue comes from this channel.
Our MPD customers have the required desalination expertise to engineer, undertake procurement for, construct, and sometimes own and
operate, large-scale desalination plants. Due to the project structures and capacities of these plants, ongoing operating costs and life cycle
costs, rather than the initial capital expenditures are the key factor in the customers’ selection of anenergy recovery device solution. As
such, MPD customers most often select our PX, which we believe offers market-leading value with the highest technological and economic
benefit. We work with our MPD customers to specify and optimize our PX solutions for their plant designs. The typical desalination and
wastewater MPD project timeline between project tender and shipment generally ranges from 16 to 36 months; however, from time-to-time,
may exceed 36 months. Each project in this channel generally represents revenue opportunities over$1 million.
Original Equipment Manufacturer. OEM customers are companies that supply equipment, packaged systems, and various operating
and maintenance solutions for small- to medium-sized desalination andwastewater plants utilized by commercial and industrial entities, and
national, state, and local municipalities worldwide. We sell to our OEM customers a broad set of our products, including our PX, hydraulic
turbochargers, high-pressure pumps, circulation booster pumps, and associated services. As it relates to desalination andwastewater OEM
projects, these projects comprise of plants processing up to 13.2 million gallons/day (50 thousand m 3/day), such as those located in hotels
and resorts, power plants, cruise ships, agricultural sectors, local and other municipal sites, and industrial facilities. In addition, these OEM
customers purchase our solutions for mobile, decentralized “quick water” or emergency water solutions. Unlike MPD projects, desalination
and wastewater OEM projects are smaller in scope and the initial capital expenditure, rather than future ongoing operating costs, is often
more of a factor in selection of anenergy recovery device solution in desalination. Accordingly, we sell not only our PX, but also our
hydraulic turbochargers, which offer a lower cost alternative to our PX. The typical desalination and wastewater OEM project timeline from
project tender to shipment generally ranges fromone to 16 months; however, from time-to-time, may exceed 16 months. Each project in this
channel typically represents revenue opportunitiesup to $1 million. Early stage revenue from these projects are dependent on the size of
system or retrofit of our customers’ projects.
Aftermarket. Aftermarket customers are desalination orwastewater plant owners and/or operators who can utilize our technology to
upgrade or keep their plant running optimally, and usually have our solutions installed and in operation. We provide spare parts, repair
services, field services and various commissioning activities. We leverage our industry expertise in supporting our existing installed base to
ensure that our energy recovery solutions are being operated effectively and efficiently in order to maximize plant availability and overall
profitability of the facility operations, as required by our industry partners and customers.
Seasonality
There is no specific seasonality to desalination or wastewater revenue. Desalination or wastewater revenue occurs throughout a
calendar year. We often experience substantial fluctuations in desalination or wastewater revenue from quarter-to-quarter and from year-to-
year primarily due to the timing and execution of our MPD shipments, which vary from year to year.
Emerging Technologies
Today, we are leveraging ourpressure exchanger technology platform to develop new product applications and diversify into new
industries. We continue to push the limits of what ourpressure exchanger technology can do, which we believe will unlock new commercial
opportunities in the future.
CO 2
The global refrigeration and heating industries are major contributors to greenhouse gas emissions, of which the leakage of
hydrofluorocarbon (“HFC”) refrigerants within these closed systems are the leading cause. HFCs have been recognized as a significant
contributor to global warming, up to thousands of times more potent than carbon dioxide (“CO 2”) used as a refrigerant. In 2016, much of the
world adopted the Kigali Amendment to the Montreal Protocol with the intent of reducing HFCs by 85% in developed nations by 2036, and
globally by 2047. The European Union’s consumption of HFCs was 55% below targets by end of 2022, and they plan to reduce by 80% by
- The U.S. first supported the reduction of HFCs in the American Innovation and Manufacturing Act in 2020, later ratified the Kigali
Amendment itself in October 2022, and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency finalized the rules in July 2023 to reduce HFC production
and imports by 70% by end of 2029, and 85% by 2036.
CO 2 used as a refrigerant is a climate-friendly alternative to greenhouse gas-emitting HFCs and has been the natural refrigerant of
choice for decades in Europe and Japan, where tens of thousands of CO 2 implementations have occurred to date. CO 2-based refrigeration
systems for commercial and industrial applications are safe, sustainable, and commercially available; however, a CO 2-based refrigeration
system can also consume significant amounts of electricity, especially in warm environments, making them expensive to operate. We believe
our PX G1300™, which uses proven pressure exchanger technology to improve CO 2-based refrigeration system performance, can contribute
to solving this challenge and help make CO 2-based refrigeration economically viable in a broader range of climates. When integrated into
new or existing systems, the PX G1300 can reduce compressor workload to increase cooling capacity, system stability, and energy
efficiency.
PX G1300. Our refrigeration-focused product leverages our existing ceramics, material science, and
manufacturing expertise. The PX G1300 can reduce the energy consumption and operating costs of CO 2-based
refrigeration systems in a broad range of operating conditions. We see this as potentially a significant accelerator for
adoption of CO 2-based refrigeration system globally as our PX G1300 could eventually alter the standard refrigeration
system architecture by reducing costs for end users, such as grocery stores.
We designed the PX G1300 to be integrated into new or existing CO 2-based refrigeration systems. The
PX G1300 can integrate with any existing rack controller and is easy to operate and maintain. We believe the simplicity
of installation and the ease of operations could encourage adoption of this new technology.
Sales and Marketing
We believe there is a significant potential market for the PX G1300 in a variety of channels, such as supermarket chains and cold
storage facilities. The build of these commercial and industrial refrigeration systems is large enough and demands enough flow of CO 2
refrigerant to warrant the use of our device, which today implies any system 80 kilowatt in size or greater.
In understanding the market for the PX G1300, we have identified three major value propositions:
- Energy Savings and Emissions Reduction. The PX G1300 recycles the high-pressure energy of a CO 2 system by compressing a
portion of the gas flow for “free.” This “free” compression provided by the PX G1300 allows the main electrical refrigeration
compressor to work less to keep the refrigeration system at the same temperature. In this way, our PX G1300 contributes to
lower energy consumption and lower costs by reducing the amount of cycles the main compressor operates, and thereby lower
emissions in a CO 2 refrigeration system.
- Increased Cooling Capacity. The PX G1300 can add compression capacity to a transcritical CO 2-based refrigeration system to
safeguard against high discharge pressure failures, which occur during heatwaves when refrigeration systems are under stress.
- Initial Capital Investment. When designed into a new CO 2-based refrigeration system, the PX G1300 may offset some initial
capital investment due to the extra compression capacity it provides, allowing for the reduction or removal of other components.
The magnitude of each of these value propositions, or lack thereof, will greatly depend on the geographic location of a refrigeration
system and temperature ranges that location experiences, the cost of energy at that location, the specific architecture of the refrigeration
system itself and possibly other parameters.
Channels and Customers
CO 2 sales are reported under our OEM sales channel. This includes direct sales to commercial or industrial customers, such as
supermarket chains, cold storage facilities, and other industrial users. Also, included are sales to intermediaries, such as refrigeration system
installers or refrigeration OEMs, to whom we sell the PX G1300 and associated services for inclusion in these customers’ entire new
packaged or retrofit of existing systems.
The commercial refrigeration market ecosystem has multiple players who integrate the components to build a system. These players
include supermarkets, which are the end users of the systems; contractors and installers that assist with the installation and maintenance of
the systems; refrigeration OEMs; and design consultants that assist in designing and specifying the systems for end users and in providing
the component specifications to the refrigeration OEMs.
We initially sold the PX G1300 to a variety of customers, such as directly to an end user supermarket chain and OEMs. We believe
that once the PX G1300 is more established, our sales process will evolve primarily to sell through OEMs, who in turn build and install
refrigeration systems at sites maintained by end users.
Competition
The concept of energy recovery is a new one in the refrigeration industry. Therefore, unlike in our water markets, there is no direct
analogous competitor to our pressure exchanger technology. However, there are a variety of cost saving methods, as well as alternative
devices, that refrigeration manufacturers may try to introduce into their configurations to reduce energy consumption within their CO 2-based
refrigeration systems. These cost saving methods include utilizing novel system architectures, new and improved equipment or materials,
ejectors or other energy recovery devices, and/or other technologies that could improve energy efficiency. These cost savings methods may
or may not be compatible with the PX G1300. As CO 2-based refrigeration systems become more prevalent, we believe competitive
technologies and devices could arise.
Seasonality
There is no specific CO 2 revenue seasonality to highlight in the early stages of this product lifecycle.
Manufacturing
Our products, including our PX, hydraulic turbochargers, high-pressure pumps, and circulation booster pumps, are designed,
manufactured, assembled, and tested in two facilities located in California. Our facilities include advanced ceramics manufacturing and
testing equipment.
We obtain raw, processed, and certain pre-machined materials from various suppliers to support our manufacturing operations. A
limited number of these suppliers are single source to maintain material consistency and support new product development. However,
although we may purchase from certain single source suppliers, we have qualified redundant source(s) to ensure consistent supply for many
of our critical raw materials and manufactured components. Alumina ceramic components for our PX products are manufactured in-house
from high-purity alumina to the final product. We are able to leverage our ceramics manufacturing across all of our PX product lines.
Through our vertically integrated ceramics precision manufacturing process, we ensure that all components meet our high standards for
quality, durability, and reliability. The components for our other products undergo final precision machining to protect the proprietary nature of
our manufacturing methods and product designs, and to maintain premium quality standards.
We are committed to reducing the environmental impact of our operations. We recognize that as we pursue our strategy of diversified
and disciplined growth, our operations and our impact on the environmentmay increase. Some of the ways we currently seek to minimize
our environmental impact are by reducing consumption of resources through waste management strategies, optimizing the use of renewable
energy, and monitoring key environmental indicators. For example, as part of our waste management strategies, during the machining
phase, when the solid components are shaped, excess high-purity alumina powder is collected, processed, and then reused. Further, we
have incorporated in our testing process multiple test loops, which allows us to test products we manufacture to their operating conditions.
These test loops, which are a major driver of our water usage, have been modified to allow us to recycle most of the water used in these
testing cycles. Our efforts to measure and manage our impact will continue to evolve as our business grows.
Research, Development and Technology
Research and development (“R&D”)has been, and remains, an essential part of ourhistory, culture and corporate strategy. Since our
formation, we have developed leading technology and engineering expertise through the evolution of ourpressure exchanger technology,
which can enhance environmental sustainability and improve productivity by reducing energy consumption in pressurized fluid-flow systems.
This versatile technology works as a platform to build product applications and is at the heart of many of ourproducts. In addition, we have
engineered and developed ancillary devices, such asour hydraulic turbochargers and circulation booster pumps that complement ourenergy
recovery devices.
Today, we are applying our pressure exchanger technology in new and important ways, building new products to accelerate
environmental sustainability across more industries. Our investments into R&D are focused on (1) advancing our solutions to better service
historical markets, such as desalination; (2) applying ourpressure exchanger technology to new markets, such as our recent entries into the
wastewater and CO 2 markets; and (3) fundamental research into new applications of ourpressure exchanger technology in existing and new
verticals.
We recognize the importance of carefully stewarding resources to support our ongoing R&D program. We maintain advanced
analytical and testing capabilities to evaluate our solutions at all company sites. We have developed complex analytical tools which allow us
to be less reliant on full-scale testing that is costly and often uses considerable amounts of water and consumable energy. Our advanced
numerical modeling and analytical tools allow for 3-dimensional, multi-phase, multi-physics, and multi-scale, computational fluid dynamics,
fluid structure interactions, thermodynamics, and system analysis. Leading-edge modeling and analytical techniques coupled with extensive
state of the art experimental capabilities allow us to further refine our existing water and refrigeration technologies, as well as developing new
derivatives of ourpressure exchanger technology for complex systems and applications.
Our highly skilled engineering team, many of whom carry accreditation from world-recognized engineering organizations, specialize in
a range of technical fields critical to support our current product lines and advance our incubation initiatives, including core engineering
competencies of fluid mechanics and aerodynamics, solid mechanics with expertise in computational fluid dynamics and finite element
analysis, bearings design (roller-element, hydrostatic, and hydrodynamic), multi-phase flow, dynamics and controls, acoustics and vibrations,
tribology, material science and coatings, pumps and turbines, turbo-machinery, and rotating equipment.
Intellectual Property
We seek patent protection for new technologies, inventions, and improvements that are likely to be incorporated into our solutions.
We rely on patents, trade secret laws, and contractual safeguards to protect the proprietary tooling, processing techniques, and other know-
how used in the production of our solutions. We have a robust intellectual property (“IP”) portfolio consisting of U.S. and international issued
patents as well as pending patent applications.
We have registered the following trademarks with the United States Patent and Trademark office: “ERI,” “PX,” “PX Pressure
Exchanger,” “Pressure Exchanger,” “Ultra PX,” “PX PowerTrain,” “PX G1300,” and the Energy Recovery logo. We have also applied for and
received registrations in international trademark offices.
Human Capital Resources
Our employees are key to our Company’s success. We believe we have a talented, motivated and dedicated team, and we work to
create an inclusive, exciting, safe, and supportive environment, for all of our employees. Our company is built around innovation and driven
by diversity of thought and background. Our employees challenge the status quo, actively partner to resolve challenges, and seek to
continuously improve themselves as well as our operations.
As of December 31, 2023, we had 269 full-time employees, which is approximately 100% of our staffing, and include both permanent
and leased employees. Our leased employees include sales and service agents worldwide, and IT support. Our employees are not
unionized, and we consider our relations with our employees to be good.
We are proud to have built a global workforce to match our global customer base. Our employees represent a broad array of
backgrounds, professionally and personally, and we believe that this diversity of experience and perspectives is a competitive advantage that
allows us to better serve the needs of our customers.
Our Code of Business Conduct (our “Code”) serves as a critical tool to help all of us recognize and report unethical conduct, while
preserving and nurturing our culture. Our Code is reflected in our employee manual, which we provide to all of our employees, and training
programs. Both our employee manual and training programs include our policies against harassment and bullying, and the elimination of
bias in the workplace.
Recruiting, Training and Retention
Our focus is to create an engaged employee experience, throughout the process of attracting, onboarding, developing, and retaining
employees. We are committed to supporting employee development as well as providing competitive benefits and a safe workplace. We
support and develop our employees through global training and development programs that build and strengthen employees’ leadership and
professional skills while striving to enhance our employee’s financial, mental and physical wellness. To assess and improve employee
retention and engagement, we survey our employees with the assistance of a third-party employee engagement survey, and take action to
address areas of employees’ concerns.
Our employee engagement efforts include newsletters and all-employee town hall meetings, as well as informational meetings, which
includes our executive staff meeting with small groups of employees in an informal setting, through which we aim to keep all of our
employees well-informed, increase transparency and promote a culture of open communication. Our values and ethics serve as the guiding
force through which we proactively maintain the highest standards of business conduct.
Compensation and Benefits
We believe that compensation should be competitive and equitable, and should enable our employees to share in our company’s
success. In addition, we recognize our employees are most likely to thrive when they have the resources to meet their needs and the time
and support to succeed in their professional and personal lives. In support of this, we offer a wide variety of benefits for our employees and
we invest in tools and resources that are designed to support our employees’ individual growth and development.
Our compensation and benefit programs are designed to recognize our employees’ contributions to value, ingenuity and business
results, including variable pay, which rewards each employee for the Company’s and individual’s performance. All full-time and full-time
equivalent employees, where allowed, are included in our share-based equity incentive program, and are offered health and welfare benefits,
mental wellness programs, development programs and training courses. In addition, all employees are afforded the opportunity to give back
to our communities through donations of time and money through our company sponsored programs.
Workplace Heath and Safety
We are committed to providing a safe and healthy workplace. We continuously strive to meet or exceed compliance with all laws,
regulations and accepted practices pertaining to workplace safety. All employees are required to comply with established safety policies,
standards and procedures, and to attend and complete annual safety training based on their job function. To accomplish our safety goals, we
developed and maintain company-wide policiesto ensure the safety of each employee, as well as compliance with domestic andinternational
safety standards. In addition, we foster work/life balance for our employees that provides significant flexibility surrounding work location and
work schedules.
Additional Information
Our website ishttps://energyrecovery.com. We also maintain an Investor Relations website as a routine channel for distribution of
important information, including news releases, presentations, and financial statements (https://ir.energyrecovery.com). We intend to use our
Investor Relations website as a means of complying with our disclosure obligations under Regulation FD. Accordingly, investors should
monitor our Investor Relations website in addition to press releases, Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) filings, and public
conference calls and webcasts. Our Annual Report on Form 10‑K, Quarterly Reports on Form 10‑Q, Current Reports on Form 8‑K, all
amendments to those reports, and the Proxy Statement for our Annual Meeting of Stockholders are made available, free of charge, in the
Investor Relations section of our website, as soon as reasonably practicable after the reports have been filed with, or furnished to, the SEC.
The information contained on our website, or any other website, is not part of this report nor is it considered to be incorporated by reference
herein or with any other filing we make with the SEC. Our headquarters and primary manufacturing center is located at 1717 Doolittle Drive,
San Leandro, California 94577, and our main telephone number is (510)483-7370. The SEC maintains an internet site that contains reports,
proxy and information statements and other information regarding issuers that file electronically with the SEC. The address of the SEC
website is http://www.sec.gov. We have included this website address only as an inactive textual reference and do not intend it to be an
active link to the SEC website.
The text of this filing, as the company filed it with the SEC, without its images or exhibits. This is not investment advice.