NU SKIN ENTERPRISES INC
For the period ended Dec 31, 2023. Filed Feb 15, 2024.
View on SEC.govAbout this filing
A company's yearly report to the SEC, with audited financial statements. It is the fullest account a company gives of its business, its finances and the risks it sees.
FY2023 · Filed Feb 15, 2024
Extracted filing text, with the paragraph anchors used by the comparison.
See the whole filing, with its images and exhibitsContents
DISTRIBUTION CHANNEL
Our Nu Skin business operates in the direct selling channel, primarily utilizing person-to-person marketing to promote and sell our products. We believe that direct selling, which has traditionally relied on face-to-face, word-of-mouth marketing, is currently being impacted by the convergence of social commerce, influencer and affiliate marketing, and the growing gig economy. These macroeconomic shifts have also disrupted traditional advertising and retail business practices, as well as e-commerce generally, in favor of socially enabled and direct-to-consumer models. The COVID-19 pandemic further accelerated disruption across many industries by causing migration to remote work, gig engagement and online shopping.
We endeavor to transform and adapt our business to these trends by helping our sales force to become more socially enabled and to grow their businesses online. In addition, we are developing more robust approaches to help our salesforce attract and develop affiliate marketers. We are currently working through a significant digital transformation in our business to achieve widespread adoption of social commerce in all of our markets. This transformation involves the development of new and enhanced digital tools for our Sales Leaders and consumers, including new digital apps and an improved website design and functionality. Our products also have served an important role in our social commerce strategy as we have developed products that are shareable and demonstrable on social media platforms. Products continue to play an important role as we transform to a more digital and socially enabled business; in particular, we believe that connected devices will provide data on consumer behaviors and needs that will engender a more personalized experience for our consumers and improved brand loyalty.
Our digital transformation will require significant expenditures over the next several years. Our digital transformation, affiliate marketing and social sharing also present certain risks and challenges to our business, and some social media platforms impose restrictions or prohibitions on content related to multi-level marketing. For further information, see Item 1A. Risk Factors.
We believe our direct selling distribution channel is an effective vehicle to distribute our products because:
| ● | our sales force has rapid reach to potential customers through their social networks and the social networks of those to whom they are connected; |
| ● | our sales force can personally educate and share company content with consumers about our products, which we believe is more effective for differentiating our products than using traditional mass-media advertising; |
| ● | our distribution channel allows for personalized product demonstrations and trial by potential consumers; |
| ● | our distribution channel allows our sales force to provide personal testimonials of product efficacy; |
| ● | as compared to other distribution methods, our sales force has the opportunity to provide consumers higher levels of personalized service based on consumers’ needs, including through providing personalized purchasing offers, discounts and regimens; |
| ● | as compared to other distribution methods, our sales force knows their customers and can foster loyalty through data-driven customer-relationship management and our subscription program; |
| ● | prospecting for customers via social networks (both offline and online) allows affiliates and the company to attract a potentially wider audience of customers who would not typically seek out similar products in a standard retail or e-commerce marketplace; and |
| ● | flexible and targeted compensation structures allow affiliates and the company to quickly enhance focus on specific products based on geographic, demographic, and seasonal needs and opportunities, as well as specific segments of customers, affiliate marketers and business builders. |
While our person-to-person marketing philosophy remains consistent globally, various aspects of our business may differ from market to market, including product mix and pricing, customer type mix, the manner and tools used to engage potential customers, social media and third-party platforms, compensation structure, the manner and tools used to engage potential affiliates (including programs and incentives), access to distribution outlets or product stores, the manner of getting products to consumers, product claims, branding and product formulations. In addition, in Mainland China we have implemented a business model that, unlike the business model we use in our other markets, utilizes retail stores, sales employees, independent direct sellers and independent marketers to market and sell our products.
Given that members of our sales force are independent contractors in most markets, we do not control or direct their business decisions or promotional efforts. We do, however, require that our sales force abide by policies and procedures that require them to act in an ethical and consumer-protective manner and in compliance with applicable laws and regulations. As a member of direct selling associations globally, we promote and abide by the industry’s codes of ethics and consumer-protective standards to support and protect those who sell and purchase our products through the direct selling channel.
In all of our markets besides Mainland China, we refer to members of our independent sales force as “Brand Affiliates” because their primary role is to promote our brand and sell products through their personal and social networks.
Consumer Group and Sales Network
Our Nu Skin business’s distribution channel is composed of two primary groups: our consumer group—individuals who buy our products primarily for personal or family consumption and share products with friends and family; and our sales network—individuals who personally buy, use and resell products, and who also attract new consumers, and recruit, train and develop new sellers. We strive to develop both our consumer group and our sales network. Our strategy for growing our consumer group is to offer high-quality, personalized, innovative products that provide demonstrable benefits. Our strategy for growing our sales network is to provide a business opportunity for those persons who demonstrate the desire and ability to develop both a consumer group and a team of sellers, including through sales compensation, incentives and recognition.
To monitor the growth trends in our consumer group, we track the number of persons who purchased directly from the company during the previous three months (“Customers”). Our Customer numbers include members of our sales force who made such a purchase, including Paid Affiliates and those who qualify as Sales Leaders, but they do not include consumers who purchase directly from members of our sales force. We believe a significant majority of Customers purchase our products primarily for personal or family consumption but are not actively pursuing the opportunity we offer to generate supplemental income by actively and consistently marketing and reselling products.
To monitor the growth in our sales network, we track the number of Paid Affiliates and Sales Leaders, which are defined as follows:
| ● | “Paid Affiliates” are any Brand Affiliates, as well as members of our sales force in Mainland China, who earned sales compensation during the previous three months. As we continue to focus on customer acquisition, our Paid Affiliates, who primarily share products, are a bridge to attracting new customers and nurturing relationships and community. Paid Affiliates power our social commerce model and are an important indicator of consumer purchasing activity in our business. |
| ● | “Sales Leaders” are the three-month average of our monthly Brand Affiliates, as well as sales employees and independent marketers in Mainland China, who achieved certain qualification requirements as of the end of each month of the quarter. |
The following chart sets forth information concerning our Customers, Paid Affiliates and Sales Leaders for the last three years. During the first quarter of 2022, in connection with the introduction of the new metric Paid Affiliates, we reviewed how we define Sales Leaders and adjusted this metric’s definition to what we believe provides a better insight into the trends of our business. We have recast the 2021 Sales Leaders to the new definition. The definition of our Customer metric remained unchanged.
Total Number of Customers, Paid Affiliates and Sales Leaders by Region
| Three Months Ended December 31, | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 2022 | 2021 | |
| Customers | |||
| Americas | 231,183 | 299,287 | 336,564 |
| Mainland China | 207,276 | 202,933 | 315,418 |
| Southeast Asia/Pacific | 106,471 | 141,183 | 169,601 |
| South Korea | 103,151 | 123,749 | 146,354 |
| Japan | 113,670 | 119,152 | 122,813 |
| Europe & Africa | 163,178 | 197,917 | 210,414 |
| Hong Kong/Taiwan | 52,110 | 62,903 | 66,395 |
| Total Customers | 977,039 | 1,147,124 | 1,367,559 |
Paid Affiliates
| Americas | 31,910 | 42,633 | 49,328 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mainland China | 25,889 | 23,436 | 30,546 |
| Southeast Asia/Pacific | 34,404 | 38,653 | 44,050 |
| South Korea(1) | 22,166 | 45,058 | 52,036 |
| Japan(1) | 22,417 | 38,021 | 38,428 |
| Europe & Africa(1) | 18,888 | 31,869 | 36,482 |
| Hong Kong/Taiwan(1) | 11,212 | 17,286 | 20,155 |
| Total Paid Affiliates | 166,886 | 236,956 | 271,025 |
Sales Leaders
| Americas | 7,126 | 9,594 | 10,879 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mainland China(2) | 11,296 | 12,359 | 18,207 |
| Southeast Asia/Pacific | 6,418 | 6,999 | 8,800 |
| South Korea | 5,249 | 6,094 | 8,224 |
| Japan | 7,086 | 5,936 | 5,864 |
| Europe & Africa | 3,968 | 4,740 | 5,743 |
| Hong Kong/Taiwan | 2,916 | 3,015 | 3,666 |
| Total Sales Leaders | 44,059 | 48,737 | 61,383 |
| (1) | The December 31, 2023 number is affected by a change in eligibility requirements for receiving certain awards within our compensation structure, to more narrowly focus on those affiliates who are actively building a consumer base. See Item 7. Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations—“South Korea,” “Japan,” “Europe & Africa,” and “Hong Kong/Taiwan,” for more information. |
| (2) | The December 31, 2023 and 2022 numbers reflect a modified Sales Leader definition. During 2022, we made some modifications to the compensation plan, which provides leaders more flexible requirements to maintain their business. |
Global Direct Selling Channel
Outside of Mainland China, individuals can elect to participate in our business as follows:
| ● | “Brand Affiliate-Direct Consumers”—Individuals who purchase products directly from a Brand Affiliate at a price established by the Brand Affiliate. |
| ● | “Company-Direct Consumers”—Individuals who purchase products directly from the company. These consumers are typically referred by a Brand Affiliate and may purchase at retail price or at a discount. These individuals do not have the right to build a Nu Skin business by reselling products or by recruiting others. |
| ● | “Basic Brand Affiliates”—Brand Affiliates who purchase products for personal or family use or for resale to other consumers. These individuals are not eligible to receive compensation on a multi-level basis unless they elect to qualify as a Sales Leader under our global sales compensation plan. We consider these individuals to be part of our consumer group, as we believe a significant majority of these Brand Affiliates are purchasing products for personal use and not actively building a sales network or consumer base. |
| ● | “Sales Leaders and Qualifiers”—Brand Affiliates who have qualified or are trying to qualify as a Sales Leader. These Brand Affiliates have elected to pursue the business opportunity as a Sales Leader and are actively attracting consumers and building a sales network under our global sales compensation plan. These Sales Leaders and Qualifiers constitute our sales network. |
To become a Brand Affiliate, an individual signs a Brand Affiliate agreement and receives access to a business portfolio, which is free in most markets. In some markets, we charge a small fee for the business portfolio. The business portfolio, generally consists of documentation concerning the business, including copies of the sales compensation plan, Brand Affiliate policies and procedures, product catalog and other documentation, but does not include products. There are no requirements to purchase products or other materials to become a Brand Affiliate, and no commissions are paid on any purchase of a business portfolio.
We offer a generous product return policy, which also includes returns of business support materials. In most markets, we offer a return policy that allows our Brand Affiliates to return unopened and unused items for up to 30 days for a full refund, or 12 months subject to a 10% restocking fee. Brand Affiliates are not required to terminate their accounts to return product. Actual returns have historically been less than 5% of annual revenue. We believe our generous return policy minimizes the financial risks associated with being a Brand Affiliate.
In addition to our product return policy, we strive to be as protective of our customers as possible. We seek to ensure that those who use our products or participate in our business opportunity are treated fairly and are not misled by inappropriate product or earnings claims.
There are two fundamental ways in which our Brand Affiliates can earn money:
| ● | through retail markups on resales of products purchased from the company; and |
| ● | through sales compensation earned on the sale of products under our global sales compensation plan. |
We believe that our global sales compensation plan is among the most generous in the direct selling industry and is one of our competitive advantages. Our Brand Affiliates can receive sales compensation for product sales from the company to their own consumer groups. Likewise, our Sales Leaders can receive sales compensation under our global sales compensation plan for product sales from the company to their own consumer groups, as well as for product sales from the company to other Sales Leaders and their consumer groups. This type of sales compensation is often referred to as “multi-level” compensation. Our sales force is not required to recruit or sponsor others, and we do not pay anysales compensation for recruiting or sponsoring. While all of our Brand Affiliates can sponsor others at any time, our Sales Leaders and those in qualification to become Sales Leaders are those who generally are the most active in sponsoring others. Pursuant to our global sales compensation plan, we pay consolidated sales compensation in a Sales Leader’s home market, in local currency, for product sales in the Sales Leader’s own consumer group and for product sales in the Sales Leader’s team of Sales Leaders across all geographic markets.
Mainland China Business Model
Because of restrictions on direct selling and multi-level commissions in Mainland China, we have implemented a business model for that market that is different from the business model we use in our other markets. We have structured our business model in Mainland China based on several factors: the guidance we have received from government officials, our interpretation of applicable regulations, our understanding of the practices of other international direct selling companies operating in Mainland China, and our understanding as to how regulators are interpreting and enforcing the regulations. The regulatory environment in Mainland China continues to be challenging and restrictive. We are currently evaluating potential changes to the structure of our sales compensation in Mainland China due to the evolving commercial and regulatory environment. These changes could have a negative impact on our sales in that market.
In Mainland China, we utilize sales employees to sell products through our retail stores, website and digital platforms; independent direct sellers, who can sell away from our stores where we have a direct selling license and a service center and can also sell through our website and digital platforms; and independent marketers, who are licensed business owners authorized to sell our products at their own approved premises or through our stores, website and digital platforms. (As used in the foregoing sentence, our digital platforms include not only those owned or run by our company but also a platform operated by a third party on which we have registered a flagship store.) We rely on our sales employees, independent direct sellers and independent marketers to attract new consumers, promote repeat purchases, and educate our sales force about our products, culture and policies through training meetings.
Our sales employees, independent direct sellers and independent marketers in Mainland China do not participate in our global sales compensation plan but are instead compensated according to a separate compensation model established for Mainland China, which is separate and different from our global compensation plan. Independent direct sellers and sales employees who have not achieved certain qualification requirements receive monthly bonuses based on their monthly product sales. Sales employees who achieve qualification requirements and independent marketers earn (1) monthly bonuses based on their monthly product sales and other bonuses based on various performance metrics; and (2) a salary (for sales employees, consisting of position pay and performance pay) or service fee (for independent marketers). The salary or service fee and position/title are reviewed and adjusted quarterly based on their performance relative to other sales leaders, taking into account such factors as the sales productivity of the Sales Leader him/herself and of the sales force that such Sales Leader trains, collaborates with, supports and services. We utilize our global system to track and assess the sales productivity of each Sales Leader him/herself and the sales force that such Sales Leader trains, collaborates with, supports and services in setting his/her salary or service fee and in connection with the evaluation of their position/title. We generally compensate our Mainland China Sales Leaders at a level that is competitive with other direct selling companies in the market and comparable to the compensation of our Sales Leaders globally.
Operating in Mainland China entails certain risks and uncertainties to our business, as discussed further in Item 1. Business—“Regulation” and Item 1A. Risk Factors. We endeavor to mitigate these risks and uncertainties through various measures, including by seeking to understand and obey laws and regulations, training our employees and sales force, engaging in dialogue with government officials to better understand their goals and explain our plans, and cooperating in inquiries and other matters of interest to regulators. However, these efforts do not eliminate the significant risks associated with operating in Mainland China.
Our global sales compensation plan and our Mainland China business model, including our related know-how, processes and systems, play a significant role in helping us to attract and incentivize our sales force. We have strategically developed and refined our global sales compensation plan and our Mainland China business model to distinguish the business opportunity that we offer from those of other companies and to seek to provide us with a competitive advantage.
Sales Incentives, Meetings, Recognition and Training
An important part of our distribution channel is motivating our Sales Leaders and recognizing their achievements. We hold regular meetings and events globally to recognize Sales Leaders who have achieved various levels of success in our business. These meetings, which may be held either virtually or in-person, also allow the company and key Sales Leaders to provide training to other Sales Leaders. We utilize a variety of sales incentives such as incentive trips to motivate Sales Leaders. In addition to rewarding performance, incentive trips provide Sales Leaders and the company opportunities to share best practices, set goals, generate alignment of Sales Leaders around key initiatives, and provide a high level of motivation and team building.
Product Launch Process
Prior to making a product generally available for purchase in a market, we often do one or more introductory offerings of the product, such as a preview of the product to our Sales Leaders or other product introduction or promotion. We refer to the entire process, beginning with the introductory offering through general availability of the product, as a product launch or our product launch process. The timing of the launch of a particular product often varies from market to market depending on such factors as customer demand, product registration or other local legal requirements, and product availability in our supply chain.
Sales Leader previews and other product introductions and promotions sometimes generate significant activity and a high level of purchasing, which can result in a higher-than-normal increase in revenue during the quarter and can skew year-over-year and sequential comparisons. We believe our product launch process attracts new Customers, Paid Affiliates and Sales Leaders to our business, increases consumer trial, and provides us with important marketing and forecasting information about our products. Please refer to Item 1A. Risk Factors for more information on risks related to our product launch process.
The text of this filing, as the company filed it with the SEC, without its images or exhibits. This is not investment advice.