RYAN SPECIALTY HOLDINGS INC
For the period ended Dec 31, 2023. Filed Feb 28, 2024.
View on SEC.govAbout this filing
A company's yearly report to the SEC, with audited financial statements. It is the fullest account a company gives of its business, its finances and the risks it sees.
FY2023 · Filed Feb 28, 2024
Extracted filing text, with the paragraph anchors used by the comparison.
See the whole filing, with its images and exhibitsContents
Item 1. Business
Overview
Founded by Patrick G. Ryan in 2010, Ryan Specialty is a service provider of specialty products and solutions for insurance brokers, agents, and carriers. We provide distribution, underwriting, product development, administration, and risk management services by acting as a wholesale broker and a managing underwriter with delegated authority from insurance carriers. Our mission is to provide industry-leading innovative specialty insurance solutions for insurance brokers, agents, and carriers.
For retail insurance brokers, we assist in the placement of complex or otherwise hard-to-place risks. For insurance carriers, we work with retail and wholesale insurance brokers to source, onboard, underwrite, and service these same risks. A significant majority of the premiums we place are bound in the E&S market, which includes Lloyd’s of London, which we refer to as Lloyd’s. There is often significantly more flexibility in terms, conditions, and rates in the E&S market relative to the Admitted or “standard” insurance market. We believe that the additional freedom to craft bespoke terms and conditions in the E&S market allows us to best meet the needs of our trading partners, provide unique solutions, and drive innovation. We believe our success has been achieved by providing best-in-class intellectual capital, leveraging our trusted and long-standing relationships, and developing differentiated solutions at a scale unmatched by many of our competitors.
Our plan for continued growth includes positioning ourselves as a pioneer in ever-changing markets, attracting and developing industry-leading talent, broadening our product offerings organically and inorganically, and further entrenching our deep industry relationships. We have been successful in each of these areas through our relentless focus on serving each of our key constituents:
Retail Insurance Brokers: Global, national, regional, and local retail insurance brokers rely on us to provide expertise in specialty insurance lines and access to the best available coverage options on behalf of insureds. Importantly, unlike some of our competitors, we have no retail operations, freeing us from potential channel conflicts with our retail brokerage trading partners.
Carriers: Insurance carriers, ranging from Lloyd’s syndicates to multi-line underwriters and E&S specialists, rely on us to provide them with highly efficient, scaled distribution, specialty brokering and underwriting management expertise, and high-quality insurance products. Insurance carriers also leverage our comprehensive distribution network and deep knowledge to gain timely and cost-efficient access to new risk classes and industries.
Our Employees: Our professionals have extensive knowledge of the industries in which they specialize and the complex insurance products we distribute and underwrite. We provide our employees with trusted retail broker and insurance carrier relationships, proprietary products and innovative solutions, which enable exceptional career advancement opportunities. We believe our reputation for helping our employees advance their careers has made us a destination of choice for many of the most talented insurance professionals in the industry.
Who We Are
We are the second-largest U.S. P&C insurance Wholesale Broker, according to premium volume reported in the 2022 Business Insurance broker rankings Special Report. Our distribution network encompasses over 700 individuals directly responsible for revenue generation in either Wholesale Brokerage or Binding Authority (each, a “Producer” and together, the “Producers”) who provide us access to over 20,000 retail insurance brokerage firms and over 250 insurance carriers. We are compensated for providing services primarily by commissions and fees.
Our business was founded to address the growing need for specialists in the increasingly important E&S market. For the year ended December 31, 2023, 78% of the total premiums we placed were in the E&S market. The growing relevance of the E&S market has been driven by the continued emergence of large, complex and high-hazard risks across many lines of insurance. These risks include more severe hurricanes that occur with greater frequency, more devastating wildfires, more frequent flooding and convective storms, escalating jury verdicts and social inflation, geographic shifts in population density, a proliferation of cyber threats, novel health risks, risks associated with large sports and entertainment venues, building and labor cost inflation relative to insured value, and the transformation of the economy to a “digital first” mode of doing business.
Compared to Admitted carriers, E&S insurance carriers often have more flexibility to quickly adjust coverage terms, pricing, and conditions in response to market needs and dynamics. This practice is commonly referred to as “freedom of rate and form,” which can facilitate coverage that would not otherwise be attainable. With greater flexibility, E&S underwriters can tailor insurance products to meet emerging risks, the needs of insureds, and the risk appetite of insurance carriers. As a result, the emergence of complex, unique or otherwise hard-to-place risks, and the need for specialty solutions, have driven meaningful growth within the E&S market.
Based on data from AM Best, the U.S. E&S market (which comprised $98 billion of direct written premium in 2022) has grown at a CAGR of 9.9%, compared to 4.7% for the U.S. Admitted market, between 2010 and 2022. E&S market share as a percentage of total U.S. commercial insurance premium increased from 13.5% in 2010 to 21.9% in 2022. We believe the higher rate of growth of the E&S market is due to the shift towards complex risks, insulating the E&S market from broader economic trends. We expect that this trend will continue.
We have been able to increase our market share by offering custom solutions and products to better address changing market fundamentals. Historically, smaller wholesale insurance brokers have relied on a go-to-market strategy that is primarily predicated on facilitating access to underwriting capacity. As risks in the E&S market continue to become more complex, increasingly global and higher hazard, simply offering market access to retail insurance brokers is no longer sufficient. We believe that as risks become more complex, the E&S market will continue to increase, wholesale brokers that do not have sufficient scale or the financial and intellectual capital to invest in the required specialty capabilities will struggle to compete effectively. This dynamic will continue the trend of market share consolidation among the wholesale insurance brokers that have these capabilities.
Our growth has been further supported by the rapid consolidation among retail insurance brokers and the consolidation of their wholesaler trading partner relationships. During 2023, retail insurance brokers completed 782 merger and acquisition (“M&A”) transactions according to OPTIS Partners, compared to 987 in 2022, 1,034 in 2021, and 795 in 2020. According to Business Insurance, this M&A velocity contributed to the Top 100 retail brokers growing revenue by over 13% in 2022. As retail brokers have become larger, they have looked to establish relationships with fewer, more trusted wholesale brokers. This approach, commonly known as “wholesale panel consolidation,” ensures that the retail brokers have quality, clarity, and consistency across their operations and insurance placement. The trend of wholesale panel consolidation started in 2011 among global retail insurance brokers and was subsequently replicated by middle-market retail brokers. We believe that retail insurance brokers favor having us on their wholesale panels as a preferred trading partner because we have national scale, top-flight talent, a full suite of product solutions, and are free from channel conflicts with their retail operations. As retail insurance brokers continue to grow and consolidate their wholesale panels, we expect that the amount of premiums we place from these existing retail broker relationships will grow.
Similarly, there has been meaningful consolidation among P&C insurance carriers over the past decade. This carrier consolidation likewise provided more opportunities for a smaller group of well-positioned insurance specialists best equipped to provide the necessary services with the requisite scale and talent.
Our core value proposition to retail insurance brokers and carriers is delivering best-in-class intellectual capital. Our people are our source of intellectual capital. We have sought to attract, develop, and retain many of the most skilled specialty insurance professionals in the industry. We seek to attract leading talent into our organization by offering a purpose-driven culture, a wide range of opportunities for career advancement and a platform for success through the breadth of our retail insurance broker relationships. We have access to over 20,000 retail insurance brokerage firms, including preferred relationships with substantially all of the top 100 retail insurance brokers. We have been highly successful in our recruiting and retention efforts and are a destination of choice for top-tier talent. Each of the cohorts of Producers hired since 2016 generated revenue which exceeded compensation costs by the end their second full year. Ensuring individual Producer book of business growth is critical for our business as it supports our organic growth, motivates our Producers, and fosters retention. In 2023, our Producer retention rate was 97%. We continue to make significant investments in people. We have formalized our Producer sourcing and development program through the establishment of Ryan Specialty University, allowing us to even more effectively cultivate talent across all specialties. We expect this program will continue to drive growth in the future.
Our Producers are able to offer retail insurance brokers multi-channel access to E&S and Admitted markets through our three Specialties: Wholesale Brokerage, Binding Authority, and Underwriting Management.
Wholesale Brokerage: Our Wholesale Brokerage Specialty operates predominantly under the brand “RT Specialty” along with others such as “RT ProExec” and “CERT.” Wholesale Brokerage distributes a wide range and diversified mix of specialty property, casualty, professional lines, personal lines, and workers’ compensation insurance products from insurance carriers to retail brokerage firms. We provide insurance carriers with efficient variable-cost distribution in all 50 states through our extensive relationships with retail brokers. For the years ended December 31, 2023 and 2022, our Wholesale Brokerage Specialty generated $1,319.1 million in net commission and fees, representing 65.1% of our net commission and fees and $1,129.2 million in net commission and fees, representing 66.0% of our net commission and fees, respectively.
Binding Authority: Our Binding Authority Specialty operates under the “RT Specialty” and “RT Binding Authority” brands. Binding Authority provides timely and secure access to our carrier trading partners that have delegated underwriting authority and critical administrative and distribution responsibilities to us through our in-house binding agreements. A significant component of our growth in a majority of this business comprises larger-volume, smaller-premium policies with well-defined underwriting criteria which allows us to combine swift turnaround with the authority to secure coverage regardless of the complexity of risk. For the years ended December 31, 2023 and 2022, our Binding Authority Specialty generated $276.0 million in net commission and fees, representing 13.6% of our net commission and fees and $231.0 million in revenue, representing 13.5% of our net commission and fees, respectively.
Underwriting Management: Our Underwriting Management Specialty operates under multiple brands, which are collectively referred to as “Ryan Specialty Underwriting Managers.” Our Underwriting Management Specialty offers insurance carriers cost-effective specialty market expertise in distinct and complex market niches underserved in today’s marketplace through 21 MGAs and MGUs, which act on behalf of insurance carriers. These carriers have provided us the authority to design, underwrite and bind coverage, and administer policies for specific risks. We also have a National Programs Platform that, together with our MGAs and MGUs, offers commercial insurance for specific product lines or industry classes. Ryan Specialty Underwriting Managers offers a broad distribution platform through a network of retail and wholesale brokers including RT Specialty. For the years ended December 31, 2023 and 2022, our Underwriting Management Specialty generated $431.6 million in net commission and fees, representing 21.3% of our net commission and fees and $351.6 million in revenue, representing 20.5% of our net commission and fees, respectively.
We have significantly enhanced our human capital, product capabilities and geographic footprint through strategic acquisitions. Since inception, we have partnered with over 50 firms through acquisition. These firms represent a diverse mix of specialties and geographies, allowing us to better service both existing and prospective trading partners. The targets that we acquired in 2023 had revenues for the unaudited twelve-month period prior to acquisition of over $95 million. We are highly selective in our M&A strategy and focus on partners that share our long-term approach, inclusive culture and commitment to integrity and client centricity. We primarily source our acquisitions through proprietary dialogue with potential partners and selectively take part in auction processes in which we believe we have a differentiated approach or value proposition. We take a consistent and disciplined approach to deal structuring and integration in order to best ensure that our partners are positioned to succeed after the acquisition.
We believe that we have a number of competitive advantages in M&A compared to our competition, including robust access to capital, freedom of channel conflict in the retail market with our retail insurance broker clients, the ability to leverage our distribution platform and back-office operations to drive revenue and cost synergies through a systematic approach to integration, and a strong underlying value proposition. We have typically sought to partner with entrepreneurs who are seeking to join a firm that can give them broader product capabilities and enhanced access to retail insurance brokers and carriers. We believe we are the partner of choice for firms and teams seeking to benefit from the resources of a larger organization without sacrificing culture, entrepreneurial spirit, and the desire to grow. We continuously evaluate acquisitions, maintain a robust pipeline, and are currently in active dialogue with several potential new partners. We have previously made, and intend to continue to pursue, acquisitions with the objective of enhancing our human capital, product capabilities, natural adjacencies, and geographic footprint.
Our largest acquisition to date is All Risks, which closed in September 2020. All Risks was the fourth largest wholesale distributor in the United States at the time of the acquisition, according to Business Insurance’s 2020 rankings. All Risks possessed some key attributes we seek in our acquisition partners: a strong track record of organic revenue growth, enhancing our market presence, accretive to our talent base, complementary in products and geography, and possessing a high-quality management team that is aligned with our culture. Members of the executive team who joined as part of the All Risks Acquisition were instrumental in developing both our national, fully integrated Binding Authority Specialty and our program platform, the latter of which is part of our Underwriting Management Specialty. We believe these capabilities complement our Wholesale Brokerage Specialty by enhancing access to specialized product offerings across our business and driving growth.
The All Risks Acquisition advanced many of our strategic priorities, including leveraging technology to drive both productivity and efficiency. Considering its expertise in binding authority, the addition of the talented All Risks team increased our capacity to cost-efficiently secure coverage for smaller-premium policies through a best-in-class operating model that drives efficiency and eliminates unnecessary data entry and duplicative work. We completed the merger of the binding authority service model, technology platform, and premium scale of All Risks with our differentiated technology platform, RT Connector, in 2023.
RT Connector is a digital marketplace through which our retail clients and internal producers can receive quotes and bind policies online. It can produce multiple bindable quotes sourced from high-quality E&S carriers across several risk classes in minutes. In cases when certain risks do not fit into RT Connector’s highly automated underwriting criteria, the retail insurance broker is automatically directed to our Producers and underwriters for more traditional placement methods. This holistic approach and integrated service model allow us to better serve retail insurance brokers because we can place their smaller-premium accounts efficiently, aggregate more of their submissions rapidly, and bind more policies for them cost-effectively. We have also connected with several “digital first” retail trading partners as a wholesale digital distributor. Under these arrangements, policies that do not fit our trading partner’s Admitted markets platform are referred directly into RT Connector platform for access to E&S solutions.
Our financial performance reflects the strength of our strategy and business model, including a 20.4% increase in revenue from both year ended December 31, 2022 to December 31, 2023 and year ended December 31, 2021 to December 31, 2022. This rapid pace of growth was accompanied by Diluted earnings per share of $0.52 in both 2023 and 2022. Our Adjusted diluted earnings per share increased from $1.15 in 2022 to $1.38 in 2023. Please see “Note 12, Earnings (Loss) Per Share” in the footnotes to the Consolidated Financial Statements in this Annual Report for additional information. Adjusted diluted earnings per share is a non-GAAP metric. For a reconciliation of Adjusted diluted earnings per share to its most directly comparable GAAP metric, Diluted earnings (loss) per share, please see “Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operation – Non-GAAP Financial Measures and Key Performance Indicators” included elsewhere in this Annual Report.
Industry Overview
As a wholesale distributor, we operate within the broader P&C insurance distribution market, which comprises both wholesale insurance brokers and retail insurance brokers. Wholesale and retail insurance brokers facilitate the placement of P&C insurance products in both the E&S and Admitted markets.
P&C Insurance Market
Insurance carriers sell commercial P&C products in the United States through one of two markets: the Admitted or “standard” market and the E&S market. Approximately 78% of U.S. premiums are generated through the Admitted market, which has highly regulated rates and policy forms. As a result, products in the Admitted market are relatively uniform in price and coverage. According to data from AM Best, the E&S market comprised $98 billion of direct written premium in 2022. In the E&S market, insurance carriers have more flexibility to customize rates and coverage. This flexibility facilitates the underwriting of risks which are characterized by a complex profile, unique nature, size or are otherwise difficult to place. The overall top five U.S. writers of E&S products in 2022 included: Berkshire Hathaway Inc., American International Group, Inc., Markel Corporation, Fairfax Financial Group, and W.R. Berkley Corporation, with whom we maintain meaningful relationships. Lloyd’s, which represents a market of 87 syndicates, is also a prominent player in the E&S space and approximately 16% of 2022 E&S premiums in the United States was for insurance coverage placed in the Lloyd’s market according to AM Best.
P&C Insurance Distribution Market
P&C insurance distribution is dependent on premium volumes in the P&C market as distributors typically receive a commission based on a percentage of the dollar amount of the premiums placed. The dollar amount of premiums placed is a function of both insurance rates and the underlying amount of coverage purchased, which is affected by broader macroeconomic conditions, capital availability, and carrier loss trends in the class of risk and/or the specific insured. There are broadly two types of insurance distributors: retail distributors (also called retail insurance brokers) and wholesale distributors. Retail insurance brokers source insurance buyers and act as an intermediary between the insurance buyer and insurance carriers. Wholesale distributors act as intermediaries between retail insurance brokers and insurance carriers by assisting in the placement of “specialty” risks that are outside of the retail insurance brokers’ core expertise, complex, high hazard or otherwise hard to place.
Wholesale Insurance Distribution Market
The wholesale insurance distribution market enhances efficiencies for both retail insurance brokers and insurance carriers. Retail insurance brokers rely on wholesale distributors, such as ourselves, to assist in securing insurance coverage for complex or specialty risks. The primary market for these insurance placements is the E&S market, where retail insurance brokers often must utilize wholesaler distributors who have distinct expertise and execution capabilities with specialized carriers. According to AM Best, over the past five years wholesalers were involved in placing on average 85% of annual E&S premiums. E&S insurance carriers rely on wholesale insurance distributors for product expertise and distribution capabilities. By leveraging Ryan Specialty as a wholesale distributor, E&S insurance carriers are able to access a national network that includes over 20,000 retail insurance brokerage firms in a highly efficient manner, while simultaneously enhancing the quality of policy submissions by using a knowledgeable counterparty. Insurance carriers also leverage our comprehensive distribution network and deep knowledge to gain timely and cost-efficient access to new risk classes and industries.
Wholesale distributors, who are typically compensated through commissions paid by the insurance carrier, share a portion of these commissions with the retail insurance broker and recognize revenue on a net basis. Wholesale distributors can also receive fees in addition to commissions for placing certain insurance policies. Wholesale distributors generally utilize one of three methods to place insurance risks into the E&S market:
Wholesale brokerage: 42% of 2022 E&S premiums were placed by wholesale insurance brokers without binding authority, according to AM Best. This method, also referred to as “open brokerage,” is most similar to our Wholesale Brokerage Specialty and includes a wide range and diversified mix of products.
Program manager, MGA/MGU: 18% of 2022 E&S premiums were placed by program managers, including MGUs and MGAs, according to AM Best. This method is most similar to our Underwriting Management Specialty and allows wholesale distributors to underwrite coverage on behalf of an insurance carrier for a specific type of risk, with relatively expansive delegated authority subject to agreed-upon guidelines and limits.
Wholesale brokerage with binding authority: 14% of 2022 E&S premiums were placed by wholesale insurance brokers with binding authority, according to AM Best. This method is most similar to our Binding Authority Specialty and utilizes in-house binding agreements, with a relatively limited scope of delegated authority, to facilitate rapid execution.
The following summarizes the U.S. insurance distribution value chain:
How We Win
We believe our success is attributable to providing best-in-class intellectual capital, leveraging our trusted and long-standing relationships, and developing differentiated solutions at a scale and level of quality unmatched by most of our competitors. These characteristics have allowed us to consistently win business and grow faster than our competition.
Compete with best-in-class intellectual capital and drive consistent innovation: Historically, wholesale distributors simply provided retail insurance brokers with E&S market access. We believe this practice is an antiquated go-to-market approach. The inherent weakness of this model has been illuminated as retail insurance brokers have consolidated and the risks placed into the E&S market have grown larger, have become more complex and are higher hazard. We are able to thrive by not just providing market access, but by also constantly offering differentiated and innovative solutions. Our professionals have extensive industry experience and deep product knowledge, allowing us to develop bespoke solutions in addition to providing distribution. By harnessing our collective knowledge, creativity, and relationships, we offer our clients and trading partners the expertise necessary to pursue new industries and new opportunities in an increasingly complex world. In order to foster our culture of innovation, we focus on recruiting, retaining, and developing the best-in-class wholesale professionals in the industry.
Deep connectivity with retail brokerage firms: While we empower our Producers to develop strong relationships with individual retail insurance brokers, we also engage with retail brokerage firms holistically. Our executive management team has long-standing relationships with the leadership teams at numerous retail brokerage firms; many of these relationships pre-date some of our management’s tenure at Ryan Specialty. Reporting to our executive management team are practice leaders who are aligned to the distribution channels within many retail brokerage firms. We employ experienced practice leaders across all broad classes of business, including property, casualty, and professional & executive liability coverages, in addition to specialists who run highly focused distribution channels such as construction, cyber, transportation, renewable energy, professional liability, medical stop loss and other employee benefits coverage, alternative risk, excess casualty, and transactional liability. Through our comprehensive connectivity with retail brokerage firms, we are able to deliver holistic, higher-quality, and more consistent solutions. We believe it takes strategic organizational design, deep existing relationships between retail brokerage firms, and executive management, practice leaders, and individual retail producers, as well as meaningful scale and top-tier talent, to achieve this level of connectivity.
Collaborative relationships with insurance carriers: We align with our carrier trading partners, providing them with access to specialized and often proprietary binding authority and underwriting management capabilities, broad distribution and deep industry expertise. We alleviate our more than 250 carrier trading partners of administrative burdens by offering 21 MGAs/MGUs and our National Programs Platform which together offer commercial insurance for specific product lines or industry classes. The diversity of our offerings enables our carrier trading partners to cost-efficiently access new risk classes in a timely manner, including on a delegated authority basis. We believe our carrier relationships are built on trust, industry credibility, and a proven track record of delivering attractive underwriting results. We work with the largest insurance carriers in the E&S industry, which have consistently provided us long-term capital support. We are trading partners with each of the top 25 U.S. E&S insurance carriers as ranked by AM Best, numerous Lloyd’s syndicates, U.K. and other international insurance companies. As a reflection of the strength of these relationships, our carrier trading partners will refer acquisition candidates to us, or proactively engage with us to develop new programs.
Comprehensive, full service product offering: Our success has been driven by our ability to provide broad and innovative product offerings that continue to meet the needs of our trading partners, regardless of complexity or risk profile. To provide this comprehensive level of service, we have developed a full suite of products, relationships, and capabilities. Our Wholesale Brokerage Producers are highly regarded for their ability to procure coverage for the largest, most complex, and high-hazard risks. Our Wholesale Brokers are able to place policies for challenging risks such as coastal properties, power generators, kidnap and ransom exposures, hospitals, trucking fleets and commercial transportation liability, large construction projects, and waste haulers. Our Binding Authority Producers are renowned for their ability to quickly bind smaller accounts with unique attributes. Our Underwriting Management Specialty offers retail and wholesale brokers a wide assortment of risk solutions for highly specialized needs, such as: renewable energy, construction, cyber, transportation, transactional liability, long-term care facilities, M&A representations and warranties, complex facilities, and catastrophe-exposed properties. Our comprehensive suite of products and services and our broad geographic footprint allow us to place coverage for nearly any risk brought to us by the over 20,000 retail insurance brokerage firms with which we do business. We believe that it would be difficult for a new entrant to replicate the intellectual capital behind the breadth and depth of our product offerings.
Free of channel conflict with retailer brokers: Our fundamental philosophy is that our clients’ interests must always come first. In developing our distribution strategy, we have proactively avoided channel conflicts with our clients, including in retail insurance distribution. Many of our competitors, including some of our largest, have taken a different approach. We believe that the divergence in strategy has facilitated and solidified our presence on the wholesale panels of nearly all of the most significant retail brokerage firms. Our position on numerous wholesale panels and aligned interests with retail insurance brokers enhances our reputation as a destination of choice for the most talented producers, enhances the market opportunity for our existing Producers and cements our position as a source of intellectual capital for insuring specialty risks.
Visionary, iconic, and aligned leadership team: We were founded by Patrick G. Ryan, a widely respected entrepreneur and global insurance leader who previously founded Aon, the second-largest global retail insurance broker, and who served as Aon’s Chairman and/or CEO for 41 years. Mr. Ryan serves as our Chairman and CEO and is joined by an experienced leadership team, each member of which has significant exposure in the wholesale distribution market. For example, Timothy W. Turner began his career in the insurance industry in 1987. Prior to joining Ryan Specialty, he was with CRC Insurance Services, Inc. for 10 years and was its President at the time of his departure. Our management team and employees also have significant alignment with stockholders. As of December 31, 2023, we had over 600 employee stockholders, including all of our top 50 Producers. Our management team and employees remain committed to our vision of market leadership by providing differentiated intellectual capital, building trusted relationships and pioneering risk solutions.
Our Strategy
We intend to grow our business by pursuing the following strategies:
Attract, retain, and develop human capital: Our people are the key to our success, so we have long focused on attracting and developing the most talented professionals in the industry. Since the beginning of 2018, we have recruited 93 Producers who are now responsible for $635 million of annual premiums (figures exclude Producers who are not associated with a discrete book of business). Each of the recruited Producer cohorts since 2016 generated revenue that exceeded compensation costs by the end of their second full year. In recent years, we have formalized our production sourcing and development program, which was substantially enhanced by All Risks University, and which has further evolved into Ryan Specialty University. This development platform allows us to cultivate talent across all levels and specialties. We are able to retain new and tenured employees alike by offering unprecedented market access, supporting Producers in growing their books and providing broad opportunities for rapid career advancement within our organization. For example, in 2023 and 2022, 81% and 83%, respectively, of our Producers grew their book of business. Our ability to retain top talent is a core objective of our strategy, exemplified by the fact that from 2019 through 2023 our annual retention rate has exceeded 97% and further highlighted by the fact that since the All Risks Acquisition was completed, as of December 31, 2023, Producer retention from All Risks has been consistent with Ryan Specialty’s historical retention rates.
Lead with innovation in an ever-changing market: We believe that change is inevitable and necessary. Accordingly, our business is built to respond to rapidly shifting market conditions by constantly looking for ways to broaden and enhance our product offerings. For example, many of our 11 de novo MGUs were formed to respond to emerging risks such as life sciences (LifeScienceRisk®), renewable energy (PERse®), excess commercial general liability (Emerald Underwriting Managers), cyber (EmergIn Risk), and professional liability (CorRisk). We developed Ryan Re Underwriting Managers, LLC (“Ryan Re”) to serve as an MGU in collaboration with Nationwide to create new opportunities for both organizations to grow their presence in the specialty lines market, which in turn expanded the reach of our underwriting management services into the reinsurance market. We created RT Connector to be a unique technology entrant into the E&S space. RT Connector allows us to better serve retail insurance brokers by placing their smaller-premium accounts efficiently, evaluating more of their submissions rapidly, and binding more policies for them cost-effectively. We believe in the relentless pursuit of innovation in order to respond to evolving market conditions and to reach underserved specialty markets. Further to this effort, we acquired Keystone Risk Partners at the end of 2022, representing our entrance into the alternative capital market and captive management business. Keystone advances our mission, allowing us to better serve our retail brokers to find innovative solutions for their clients. It also represents a niche growth opportunity in E&S to build and design coverage structures for some of the most complex risks, while allowing insureds greater control over their long-term insurance costs.
In 2023, we completed the acquisition of three companies that specialize in broking, distributing and underwriting employee benefits insurance products and services: ACE Benefit Partners, Point6 Healthcare, and AccuRisk Holdings. These acquisitions are core to our employee benefits platform, enabling us to provide our retail broker clients and other trading partners with employee benefits specialty products and services, including medical stop loss, group benefit captives, pharmacy, voluntary benefits, care management, and an integrated health solution. Our employee benefits practice extends our addressable market and provides additional value to our retail broker clients and their insureds. We have identified the following markets as near-term potential growth opportunities: employee benefits, nursing homes and other long-term care facilities, alternative risk offerings, cyber, transportation, life-sciences, public entities and municipalities, sports and entertainment venues, high net worth property, and New York construction and habitational spaces.
Pursue strategic acquisitions and align interests to enhance the network effect: Since our inception, we have a history of successfully executing and integrating acquisitions across a diverse mix of specialties and geographies. Our acquisition strategy is centered on increasing our intellectual capital, distribution reach, and product capabilities, which mutually reinforce one another. We take a consistent and disciplined approach to deal structuring and integration in order to ensure both that our partners are positioned to succeed after the acquisition and interests are aligned between ourselves and our new teammates. When we acquire Wholesale Brokerage businesses, they gain access to over 20,000 retail insurance brokerage firms, including preferred relationships with substantially all of the top 100 retail insurance brokers and exclusive product capabilities. When we acquire Underwriting Managers, they gain access to our wholesale Producers, deep carrier relationships, and visionary leadership. As we continue to grow, these positive network effects become stronger. The connectivity among our Specialties, as well as with key trading partners, enhances the value of our platform to recruited Producers and presents a highly attractive value proposition to acquisition partners.
Deepen and broaden our relationships with retail broker trading partners: Retail insurance brokers have multiple wholesale distribution relationships, even those that have consolidated their wholesale panels. We believe we have the ability to transact in even greater volume with nearly all of our existing retail brokerage trading partners. For example, in 2023, our revenue derived from the Top 100 firms (as ranked by Business Insurance) expanded faster than our 2023 organic revenue growth rate of 15.0%. Key to deepening our relationships with retail insurance brokers will be expanding our product offerings and enhancing our geographic footprint through organic initiatives, continued producer hires, and strategic acquisitions. In addition to deepening our relationships with existing clients, we will continue to broaden our footprint by establishing new retail broker trading partner relationships. Beyond the traditional wholesale P&C opportunities, we also expect to continue to expand our alternative risk offerings and our wholesale employee benefits specialty.
Build the largest and most comprehensive national binding authority business: We believe that both M&A consolidation and panel consolidation are in nascent stages in the binding authority market, providing us with meaningful growth opportunities. National scale in E&S distribution, underwriting expertise, and broad access to carrier capacity are key to building a cohesive binding authority platform. We have been diligently focused on all three elements and our efforts accelerated with the All Risks Acquisition, which is renowned for its binding authority capabilities. With a nationally scaled binding authority operation, as well as the capabilities existing within our Underwriting Management Specialty, we expect to be able to comprehensively address the opportunities in the delegated authority market, which represented 32% of E&S premiums in 2022 according to AM Best.
Invest in operations, invest in growth: We have heavily invested in building a durable business that is able to adapt to the continuously evolving E&S market. These investments include core operational functions, ongoing new hire efforts, a visionary management team, and a robust acquisition integration effort. In addition, we have amassed a large underlying data set based on the over 2.5 million total policy submissions we receive annually. We expect to leverage this data set to further refine our pricing models, enhance our placement advice, and increase our efficiency. Even while deliberately making these investments, we have been able to generate substantial cash flow and drive operating leverage. We have historically used our cash flow to invest in the business and fund acquisitions. We expect to continue fortifying our platform to support future expansion and sustain significant organic growth.
Our Specialties
Wholesale Brokerage
Our Wholesale Brokerage Specialty is primarily focused on specialty insurance products that retail brokers and carriers have difficulty placing on their own due to the unique nature or size of the risk. Our Wholesale Brokerage professionals are creative and highly skilled problem solvers, assisting retail insurance brokers in crafting customized solutions. We pride ourselves on providing strategic advice, from coverage strategy and conception all the way through claims activity. To achieve optimal client outcomes, our professionals utilize both their expertise and our leading capabilities and resources. For the year ended December 31, 2023, our Wholesale Brokerage Specialty generated $1,319.1 million in net commission and fees, representing 65.1% of our total net commission and fees. Wholesale Brokerage operates predominantly under the brand “RT Specialty.”
Our Wholesale Brokers distribute a wide range and diversified mix of specialty insurance products from insurance carriers to retail insurance brokerage firms. Our largest distribution channels include (among others):
Property coverages: Real Estate (Condos, Vacant Property), Catastrophic Exposures (Coastal Wind, Flood, Earthquake, Terrorism), Specialized Coverage (Deductible Buy-Backs, Large Deductible Placements), Builder’s Risk, Distribution / Warehousing, Group Programs, Healthcare Risks.
Casualty coverages: Construction (Project Specific, Residential and Commercial Contractor), Real Estate (Habitational / OL&T / Lessors Risk), Life Sciences, Healthcare, Environmental, Primary and Excess Auto, Political Risks, Liquor Liability.
Professional & Executive Liability coverages: Private Company Management Liability, Public Company Directors and Officers Liability, Financial Institutions Management Liability, Not-For-Profit Organization Management Liability, Crime / Kidnap / Ransom, Privacy Liability and Network Security, Errors and Omissions Liability, Medical Professional Liability.
Transportation coverages: Local and Long Haul Trucking, Haz-Mat Haulers, Contractors Fleets, Home Delivery, Non-Emergency Medical Transport, Waste Haulers, Auto Haulers.
Personal Lines coverages: Homeowners (Condo Unit Owner, Contents In-Storage, High Value Homeowners, Home-Based Business Product, Manufactured Homes), Farm & Ranch, Flood, Recreational (Collector Vehicle, All Terrain, Snowmobile, Watercraft).
Our Wholesale Brokerage Specialty has extensive relationships with blue-chip insurance carriers and retail insurance brokers. With regard to entities that our Wholesale Brokerage Specialty has a relationship with, there are no material concentrations in retail insurance brokers (top five: 27.6% of 2023 revenue), insurance carriers (top five: 21.9% of 2023 revenue), or internal Producers (top five: 16.1% of 2023 revenue). These concentration statistics reflect both Wholesale Brokerage and Binding Authority Specialties, as many producers utilize both placement strategies. During 2023, we conducted business with thousands of retail brokerage firms, including substantially all of the 100 largest United States retail brokers as identified by Business Insurance in 2022. We also work with small to mid-size retail brokerage firms that do not have direct access to certain of the insurance carriers with which we do business. We continue to benefit from the consolidation of wholesale broking relationships by many retail brokers due to our expertise, execution, and absence of conflicts with most retail brokers’ core businesses.
Binding Authority
We believe our Binding Authority Specialty to be among the largest binding authority platforms in the nation. For the year ended December 31, 2023, our Binding Authority Specialty generated $276.0 million in net commission and fees, representing 13.6% of our total net commission and fees. Our Binding Authority Specialty also operates under the brands “RT Specialty” and “RT Binding Authority.”
Binding Authority provides timely and secure access to our carrier trading partners that have granted relatively limited delegated underwriting authority to us through our in-house binding agreements. Much of this business comprises larger-volume, smaller-premium policies with well-defined underwriting criteria that allows us to combine swift turnaround with the authority to secure coverage regardless of the complexity of risk. The ability to quickly process higher volume policies endows us with a significant efficiency advantage over our competitors attempting to individually place each risk.
Our Binding Authority Producers distribute a curated collection of products to our retail insurance broker trading partners. Our industry distribution channels include (among others):
General Liability: Manufacturing, Start Ups, Contractors, Liquor, Plowing.
Property: Vacant, Coastal, Distressed, Warehouse, Subsidized Housing, Student Housing.
Other: Workers’ Compensation, Builder’s Risk, Contractor’s Equipment, Motor Truck Cargo, Hole-In-One, Crime.
Underwriting Management
Our Underwriting Management Specialty operates under multiple brands, which are collectively referred to as “Ryan Specialty Underwriting Managers.”
Underwriting Management offers insurance carriers cost-effective, specialty market expertise in distinct and complex market niches underserved in today’s marketplace through MGAs and MGUs, which act on behalf of insurance carriers that have given us relatively broad authority to underwrite and bind coverage, as well as critical product design, administrative and distribution responsibilities, for specific risks, and (often proprietary) National
Programs that offer commercial and personal insurance for specific product lines or industry classes. Professionals in the Underwriting Management Specialty often have a meaningful percentage of their compensation tied to underwriting performance to align interests with those of our carrier trading partners. For the year ended December 31, 2023, our Underwriting Management Specialty generated $431.6 million in net commission and fees, representing 21.3% of our total net commission and fees.
Our Organizational Structure
The Company is the sole managing member of New LLC. New LLC was formed as a Delaware limited liability company on April 20, 2021, for the purpose of becoming, subsequent to our IPO, an intermediate holding company between Ryan Specialty Holdings, Inc., and Ryan Specialty, LLC. Pursuant to contribution agreements, on September 30, 2021, the Company, the non-controlling interest LLC Unitholders and New LLC exchanged equity interests in Ryan Specialty, LLC for LLC Common Units in New LLC, with the intent that New LLC be the new holding company for Ryan Specialty, LLC interests. As Ryan Specialty, LLC is substantively the same as New LLC, for the purpose of this document we will refer to both New LLC and Ryan Specialty, LLC as the “LLC”.
Our Recent Acquisitions
In January 2023, Ryan Specialty acquired certain assets of Griffin Underwriting Managers, which enhances our market presence in the Pacific Northwest, provides access to new appointments with critical carriers in this market, and allows us to better attract high quality production talent in this market.
In July 2023, the Company acquired certain assets of ACE Benefit Partners, Inc., a medical stop loss general agent headquartered in Eagle, Idaho, and Point6 Healthcare, LLC, a distributor of medical stop loss insurance and pharmacy solutions, and a provider of complex claims management services on behalf of retail brokers and third-party administrators, headquartered in Plano, Texas. Both ACE and Point6 provide foundational benefits capabilities to Ryan Specialty.
Also in July 2023, the Company acquired 100% of the equity of Socius Insurance Services, a national wholesale insurance broker headquartered in Northern California. Socius became part of RT Specialty and deepened our talent pool in complex lines of business such as management, professional, and cyber liability, as well as property and casualty insurance.
In December 2023, the Company acquired 100% of the equity of AccuRisk Holdings, LLC, a medical stop loss managing general underwriter located in Chicago, Illinois, thereby adding depth to our growing employee benefits practice.
Also in December 2023, the Company announced that it signed a definitive agreement to acquire Castel Underwriting Agencies Limited, a Managing General Underwriting (MGU) platform. Castel is headquartered in London, England with additional offices in the Netherlands and Belgium and operations in Singapore.
Seasonality
Our Wholesale Brokerage and Binding Authority Specialties typically experience higher revenues in the second and fourth calendar quarters of each year, primarily due to the timing of policy renewals. Our Underwriting Management Specialty typically experiences higher revenues in the fourth quarter, primarily due to the timing of policy renewals.
Clients
The insureds served by our clients operate in many businesses and industries throughout the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, Europe, and certain other countries in which our subsidiaries operate. Our clients are retail brokers and agents, other intermediaries, and insurance carriers. The top five retail brokers in the United States account for 20.3% of our revenue, and no single retail broker accounted for more than 9.0% of total revenue in 2023. No carrier accounted for more than 7.3% of total revenue in 2023 (excluding all Lloyd’s syndicates combined).
Tax Receivable Agreement
We entered into the Tax Receivable Agreement with current and certain former LLC Unitholders. The Tax Receivable Agreement provides for the payment by us to the current and certain former LLC Unitholders, collectively, of 85% of the net cash savings, if any, in U.S. federal, state, and local income taxes that we actually realize (or in some circumstances are deemed to realize) as a result of (i) certain increases in the tax basis of assets of the LLC and its subsidiaries resulting from purchases or exchanges of LLC Common Units (“Exchange Tax Attributes”), (ii) certain tax attributes of the LLC and its subsidiaries that existed prior to the IPO (“Pre-IPO M&A Tax Attributes”), (iii) certain favorable “remedial” partnership tax allocations to which we become entitled (if any), and (iv) certain other tax benefits related to our entering into the Tax Receivable Agreement, including certain tax benefits attributable to payments that we make under the Tax Receivable Agreement (“TRA Payment Tax Attributes” and collectively with Exchange Tax Attributes and Pre-IPO M&A Tax Attributes, the “Tax Attributes”).
The rights of the current and certain former LLC Unitholders under the Tax Receivable Agreement are assignable. We expect to benefit from the remaining 15% of the tax benefits, if any, that we may actually realize. The actual Tax Attributes, as well as any amounts paid to the current and certain former LLC Unitholders under the Tax Receivable Agreement, will vary depending on a number of factors, including the timing of any future exchanges, the price of shares of our Class A common stock at the time of any future exchanges, the extent to which such exchanges are taxable, and the amount and timing of our income and applicable tax rates. The payment obligations under the Tax Receivable Agreement are obligations of Ryan Specialty Holdings, Inc., and not of the LLC. The Tax Receivable Agreement provides that if (i) certain mergers, asset sales, other forms of business combination or other changes of control were to occur or (ii) we breach any of our material obligations under the Tax Receivable Agreement, then the Tax Receivable Agreement will terminate and our obligations, or our successor’s obligations, to make payments under the Tax Receivable Agreement would accelerate and become immediately due and payable. The amount due and payable in that circumstance is based on certain assumptions, including an assumption that we would have sufficient taxable income to fully utilize all potential future tax benefits that are subject to the Tax Receivable Agreement.
Intellectual Property
We rely on a combination of copyright, trademark, trade dress, and trade secret laws in the United States and other jurisdictions, as well as confidentiality procedures and contractual restrictions, to establish and protect our intellectual property and proprietary rights. These laws, procedures, and restrictions provide only limited protection.
We have trademarks in the United States for “Ryan Specialty” and “RT Specialty.” The logo design for RT Specialty, and numerous of our other brand names and logos, are registered as trademarks in the United States and other jurisdictions. We have also registered numerous internet domain names related to our business. Some of our most important brand names are not yet registered, and we rely on common-law trademark protection to protect this intellectual property.
We enter into agreements with our employees, contractors, clients, partners, and other parties with which we do business to limit access to, and disclosure of, our proprietary information. We cannot assure that the steps we have taken will be sufficient or effective to prevent the unauthorized access, use, copying or the reverse engineering of our proprietary information, including by third parties who may use our proprietary information to develop products and services that compete with ours. Moreover, others may independently develop products or services that are competitive with ours or that infringe on, misappropriate, or otherwise violate our intellectual property and proprietary rights, and policing the unauthorized use of our intellectual property and proprietary rights can be difficult. The enforcement of our intellectual property and proprietary rights also depends on any legal actions we might bring against any such parties being successful, but these actions are costly, time-consuming and may not be successful, even when our rights have been infringed, misappropriated or otherwise violated.
Furthermore, effective copyright, trademark, trade dress, and trade secret protection may not be available in every country in which our products are available, as the laws of some countries do not protect intellectual property and proprietary rights to as great an extent as the laws of the United States. In addition, the legal standards relating to the validity, enforceability, and scope of protection of intellectual property and proprietary rights are uncertain and still evolving.
Companies in the insurance industry may own large numbers of copyrights, trademarks, and other intellectual property and proprietary rights, and these companies and entities have and may in the future request license agreements, threaten litigation or file suit against us based on allegations of infringement, misappropriation or other violations of their intellectual property and proprietary rights.
See “Risk Factors — Risks Related to Legal, Regulatory and Intellectual Property Issues” included elsewhere in this annual report for a more comprehensive description of risks related to our intellectual property.
Regulation
Licensing
Our business activities are subject to licensing requirements and extensive regulation under the laws of the countries in which we operate, as well as state laws. Regulatory authorities in the states or countries in which our operating subsidiaries conduct business may require individual or company licensing to act as producers, brokers, agents, third-party administrators, managing general agents, reinsurance intermediaries, or adjusters.
Under the laws of most states in the United States and most foreign countries, regulatory authorities have relatively broad discretion with respect to granting, renewing, and revoking producers’, brokers’, and agents’ licenses to transact business in such state or country. The operating terms may vary according to the licensing requirements of the particular state or country, which may require that a firm operate in the state or country through a local corporation. Our subsidiaries must comply with laws and regulations of the jurisdictions in which they do business. These laws and regulations are enforced by federal and state agencies in the United States. In the United Kingdom we are regulated by governmental agencies including the Financial Conduct Authority (“FCA”) and Prudential Regulation Authority, and we are licensed and regulated by the Lloyd’s insurance market.
Excess and Surplus Compliance
The E&S market generally provides insurance for businesses that are unable to obtain coverage from Admitted insurance carriers because of their high or complex risk profile or the unique nature or size of the risk. The surplus lines transaction is facilitated through a licensed and regulated surplus lines broker. It is the licensed surplus lines broker that is responsible for: (i) selecting an eligible surplus lines insurer; (ii) reporting the surplus lines transaction to insurance regulators; (iii) remitting the premium tax due on the transaction to state tax authorities; and (iv) assuring compliance with all the requirements of the surplus lines codes. State surplus lines laws, or laws pertaining to non-admitted insurance business, require that surplus lines brokers comply with diligent search/exempt commercial purchaser laws and affidavit/document filing requirements, as well as requiring the collection and paying of any taxes, stamping fees, assessment fees, and other applicable charges on such business. Surplus Lines brokers are often subject to special licensing, surplus lines tax, and/or due diligence requirements by the home state of the insured. Fines for failing to comply with these Surplus Lines requirements, specifically for failing to comply with the surplus lines licensing or due diligence requirements, vary by state but can range to several hundred thousand dollars.
Fiduciary Funds
Insurance authorities in the United States, United Kingdom, and certain other jurisdictions in which our subsidiaries operate have also enacted laws and regulations governing the retention and investment of funds, such as premiums, claims proceeds and premium taxes, held in a fiduciary capacity for others. These laws and regulations generally require the segregation of these fiduciary funds and limit the types of investments that may be made with them.
Broker Compensation
Some states permit insurance agents to charge policy fees, while other states limit or prohibit this practice. Many states regulate to some degree the fees that may be charged by brokers. In recent years, several states considered new legislation or regulations regarding the compensation of brokers by insurance carriers. The proposals ranged in nature from new disclosure requirements to new duties on insurance agents and brokers in dealing with clients.
Privacy and Data Security
Federal law and the laws of many states require financial institutions and entities involved in health care insurance to protect the privacy and security of personal information. Many of these laws require notice about policies and practices relating to collection and disclosure of personal information and regulate its retention, use, disclosure, and disposal. Many states have adopted strict cybersecurity laws and regulations requiring that we adopt security standards to protect personal information and provide notification of cybersecurity incidents under certain circumstances. In addition, we are also subject to laws granting individuals the right to access, amend, or delete their personal data. In the coming year, regulators are expected to take additional action to regulate artificial intelligence and automated decision-making that uses personal information and affects individuals. Regulators are also expected to step up enforcement of existing privacy law.
Competition
The wholesale brokerage business is highly competitive and very fragmented, although there are a limited number of truly national players. Our main competitors are national insurance wholesale brokers, as well as numerous specialist, regional, and local firms in almost every area of our business. We also compete with insurance and reinsurance carriers that market and service their insurance products without the assistance of brokers or agents. Competition also comes from other businesses that do not fall into the categories above, including commercial and investment banks and consultants that provide risk-related services and products.
Key competitive factors in our market include:
expertise and intellectual capital;
market access and/or product availability; and
client service.
We believe that we compete favorably on these factors.
Human Capital Management
Our culture is the foundation of everything we do. Our employees are our greatest asset, and we strive to foster a productive and empowering work environment that embodies our core values: Integrity, Client Centricity, Teamwork, Inclusion, Empowerment, Innovation, and Courage. Our key differentiators are not only our talent and expertise but also the creativity and execution we deliver on behalf of our clients. Our commitment to attracting and retaining top industry talent to assist our clients is matched only by our entrepreneurial spirit and passion for excellence.
As of December 31, 2023, we employed approximately 4,350 people with 110 offices across the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, Europe, and Singapore. We also engage temporary employees and consultants and none of our employees are represented by unions. We offer competitive compensation and benefits programs in order to attract and retain top talent. We have high employee engagement and ownership, low turnover and consider our current relationship with our employees to be very good.
Ryan Specialty is committed to building, growing, and sustaining a diverse workforce reflective of society throughout the entirety of the organization. We aspire to cultivate a company that is both inclusive and equitable, where every employee is recognized and assessed based on their performance and contributions. With leadership support and sponsorship, we strive to further evolve our Diversity, Equity & Inclusion program to foster a culture where all employees can thrive and excel. Our values set the foundation for what our Company represents, and we are proud to have “Inclusion” as a core value as it creates a culture and environment where people can be their best self and do their best work; but more importantly, we harness our differences and commonalities to better serve our clients, trading partners, workforce, and communities.
The attraction, development, and retention of employees is a critical factor in our success. As a result, we provide training and development programs for our newest teammates, that embed teaching of our core values, along with those essential critical elements of building an inclusive environment. Our training approach is critical for our future growth and ability to recruit and develop the best of the best. We also partner with a number of nonprofit, community, and industry organizations to attract, support, develop, and retain diverse talent.
Availability of SEC Filings
Our internet address iswww.ryanspecialty.com. We are subject to the informational requirements of the Exchange Act and, in accordance therewith, we file annual, quarterly and current reports and other information with the SEC. Copies of our reports on Forms 10-K, 10-Q, 8-K and all amendments to those reports filed with the SEC, and any reports of beneficial ownership of our Common Stock filed by executive officers, directors and beneficial owners of more than 10% of our outstanding common stock are posted on, and may be obtained through, our investor relations website, ir.ryanspecialty.com, or may be requested in print, at no cost, by email at ir@ryanspecialty.com or by mail at Ryan Specialty Holdings, Inc., 155 North Wacker Drive, Suite 4000, Chicago, Illinois 60606, Attention: Investor Relations.
The text of this filing, as the company filed it with the SEC, without its images or exhibits. This is not investment advice.